The short answer
At a musical theatre audition, it’s usually best to avoid:
- Heavily overdone songs that the panel may hear many times a day.
- Songs closely tied to one famous performer, which invite direct comparison.
- Songs with very difficult piano parts that an accompanist may struggle to sight-read.
- Songs from the show you’re auditioning for, unless the notice asks for them.
- Songs that don’t suit the style of the show or your voice and casting type.
- Songs you can’t sing well on a nervous day.
None of these are absolute rules. Directors and casting teams differ, and a well-chosen, well-sung song will usually beat a “safe” song sung poorly. But avoiding these common pitfalls gives you a better chance of being heard for what you do best.
Songs that often work against you
Heavily overdone songs
Some songs are so popular with auditioners that panels hear them constantly. When a song is very familiar, it’s harder to make a fresh impression, and the panel may already have a fixed idea of how it should sound.
Songs that frequently appear on informal “overdone” lists include numbers such as “On My Own” (Les Misérables), “Popular” and “Defying Gravity” (Wicked), “Tomorrow” (Annie) and some recent hits from shows like Dear Evan Hansen and Hamilton. These lists change over time as new shows become popular, and opinions vary. If you love one of these songs and sing it brilliantly, it isn’t forbidden. It’s just a harder path.
Songs tied to one famous performance
Some songs are strongly associated with a particular star. “Don’t Rain on My Parade” from Funny Girl is a common example. Singing one of these can invite a comparison with a performance the panel knows very well. It can be safer to choose a less familiar song that shows the same qualities.
Songs with very difficult accompaniment
At many auditions, a pianist you’ve never met will play for you, often sight-reading. Songs with dense, fast or rhythmically complex piano parts, including some numbers by Stephen Sondheim or Jason Robert Brown, can be hard to play well at first sight. If the accompaniment falls apart, your audition can too. Unless you know the pianist can handle it, choose music that’s clear and readable.
Songs from the show you’re auditioning for
Many directors prefer not to hear songs from the show being cast in a first-round audition, unless they’ve specifically asked for them. They may want to see what you bring on your own terms before hearing you in their material. Always read the audition notice. If it asks for a song from the show, or a song “in the style of” the show, follow that.
Songs that don’t fit the style of the show
A song that shows you can sing the style of the show is usually more useful to the panel than a song from a completely different genre. For a golden-age musical, a classic legit or traditional musical theatre song may be best. For a rock musical, a contemporary or rock-influenced song. Pop songs, or covers in the style of TV musical shows, are often discouraged unless the notice asks for them.
Songs outside your range or type
Choose a song that sits comfortably in your voice and shows off your best notes, not one that pushes you to the edge of your range. It also helps if the song suits roles you could realistically be cast in, by age, voice type and character.
Songs that need too much context
Some songs only make sense in the middle of a scene, or depend on dialogue and plot setup. Others show a character in an extreme emotional state. In a short audition, songs like these can be confusing or leave an odd impression. A song with a clear emotional journey you can act in 16 or 32 bars usually works better.
Lyrics that don’t suit the setting
For school, youth and community auditions, consider whether the lyrics are appropriate for your age and for the audience and panel. Very explicit or adult content can distract from your performance.
Practical mistakes that matter as much as song choice
The wrong length
Many auditions ask for a short cut, such as 16 bars or 32 bars, or “about a minute.” Prepare your cut in advance, mark it clearly, and practise it so it has a beginning, middle and end. Singing far longer than asked can come across as not following instructions.
Sheet music problems
Bring your sheet music:
- In the key you sing it in.
- In a binder, with pages in plastic sleeves or taped so they lie flat and turn easily.
- Clearly marked with your start and end points, any repeats, cuts and tempo.
- Complete, with the piano part, not just a lead sheet, unless you know a lead sheet is acceptable.
Take a moment to show the accompanist your start, your end and your tempo before you begin.
A cappella and backing tracks
Don’t plan to sing a cappella (without accompaniment) unless the notice says it’s fine. Likewise, don’t assume you can use a backing track on your phone unless the notice says so. Some auditions use tracks; many use a pianist.
A song you don’t know well enough
A song you learned last week may fall apart under pressure. Pick something you’ve sung many times and could perform well even if you’re nervous or tired.
What to sing instead
Rather than looking for a “perfect” song on a list, look for one that:
- Suits your voice and shows your strongest range.
- Fits the style of the show and roles you could play.
- Has a clear story or emotional journey you can act.
- Is less familiar to panels, but not so obscure it’s hard to play.
- Has a readable piano part.
- Can be cut cleanly to the length asked for.
- You genuinely enjoy singing.
A voice teacher, music director or experienced performer can help you build a small book of audition songs in contrasting styles so you’re ready for different shows.
A quick song-choice checklist
- Sits comfortably in my range
- Fits the style of the show I’m auditioning for
- Not from the show being cast (unless requested)
- Not one of the most overdone songs right now
- Readable accompaniment
- Cut to the right length and clearly marked
- In my key, in a binder
- Something I can sing well on a bad day
Song choice is only part of the picture. For what to wear on the day, see how to dress for a musical theatre audition.