Theatre Styles

Naturalism vs Realism in Theatre: What's the Difference?

Naturalism vs realism in theatre: how the two styles differ in outlook, characters, plot and staging, why the terms get mixed up, and how to stage each one.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Where both came from
  3. Realism
  4. Naturalism
  5. Side-by-side comparison
  6. Why the terms get confused
  7. How they look on stage
  8. Staging a realistic or naturalistic play in a community theatre
  9. Legacy

The short answer

Realism shows ordinary life on stage in a believable way, with everyday settings, everyday speech and psychologically convincing characters who make choices. Naturalism goes a step further: it tries to reproduce life in exact, often harsh detail and to show how people are shaped, and often trapped, by their heredity and environment.

A rough way to remember it: realism asks “Is this believable?” Naturalism asks “Is this exactly how life is, and what forces made it this way?”

In practice the two overlap so much that many plays, productions and teachers use the terms almost interchangeably. The differences matter most when you’re studying theatre history or discussing a specific production style.

Where both came from

Both styles grew up in the second half of the 19th century as a rebellion against the theatre that dominated the period: melodrama, romantic verse drama, and the neat, contrived “well-made play.” Audiences of the time were used to painted backdrops, stock heroes and villains, and plots wrapped up with coincidences.

New ideas were changing how people thought about human beings. Charles Darwin’s work on evolution, the growth of science and medicine, industrialization and new social problems all pushed writers to look harder at real life, including its ugly parts.

Realism

Realism aimed to put recognizable people in recognizable situations and let the drama come from their relationships, choices and social pressures.

Typical features:

  • Middle-class settings: parlors, studies, dining rooms
  • Everyday prose dialogue rather than verse
  • Characters with psychological depth and inner lives, often revealed through subtext
  • Social issues explored through personal situations, such as marriage, money, reputation and duty
  • Plots that are shaped and selected for dramatic effect, even if they avoid tidy happy endings
  • Actors behaving as if the audience isn’t there, behind an imaginary “fourth wall”

Key playwrights and plays: Henrik Ibsen (A Doll’s House, Hedda Gabler, Ghosts), Anton Chekhov (The Seagull, Uncle Vanya, The Cherry Orchard) and George Bernard Shaw, who mixed realism with argument and wit. Realism later became the main tradition of 20th-century American drama, in plays such as Arthur Miller’s All My Sons, Lorraine Hansberry’s A Raisin in the Sun and Eugene O’Neill’s Long Day’s Journey into Night.

On the production side, Konstantin Stanislavski and the Moscow Art Theatre (founded 1898) became famous for their careful, detailed productions of Chekhov, and Stanislavski’s acting system grew out of the search for truthful performance in this kind of play.

Naturalism

Naturalism was more of a deliberate program. The French novelist Émile Zola argued that theatre should study human beings as a scientist would, observing how heredity and environment determine behavior. He set out these ideas in essays and in his preface to the stage version of his novel Thérèse Raquin.

Typical features:

  • Often working-class or poor characters in grim settings
  • A deterministic outlook: people have little real freedom; their circumstances and biology drive them
  • Taboo or “low” subjects such as poverty, disease, alcoholism, sexuality and violence
  • “Slice of life” structure, with less obvious dramatic shaping and fewer neat climaxes
  • Extremely detailed, real stage environments: working kitchens, real objects, real food

Key figures and plays: August Strindberg’s Miss Julie, whose preface is a famous naturalist statement; Maxim Gorky’s The Lower Depths; Gerhart Hauptmann’s The Weavers; Zola’s Thérèse Raquin.

The French director André Antoine, who founded the Théâtre Libre in Paris in 1887, pushed staging toward naturalism with real furniture and props. He is often credited with hanging real sides of beef on stage for a play set in a butcher’s shop.

Side-by-side comparison

Realism Naturalism
Outlook People make choices within social pressures People are largely determined by heredity and environment
Typical class Mostly middle class Often working class and poor
Subject matter Domestic and social problems Harsh, often taboo realities
Plot Shaped and selected for drama Looser “slice of life”
Detail Believable and selective As complete and exact as possible
Influences Social change, psychology Darwin, science, Zola’s theories
Key writers Ibsen, Chekhov, Shaw, Miller Zola, Strindberg, Gorky, Hauptmann

Why the terms get confused

There are three main reasons.

1. They really do overlap. Naturalism grew out of realism, and many plays sit between the two. Some critics call Ibsen’s Ghosts naturalistic because of its focus on inherited disease; Chekhov is usually called a realist, but productions of his plays at the Moscow Art Theatre were noted for their naturalistic detail.

2. “Naturalistic” also describes acting. People often say an actor gives a “naturalistic” performance when they mean it’s subtle and believable. That describes a way of acting, not the 19th-century movement.

3. School drama uses the words differently. In many UK drama courses in particular, “naturalism” is commonly used to describe Stanislavski-based, truthful acting and fourth-wall staging, almost the same as what American textbooks call realism. If your teacher or exam board uses the terms a particular way, follow their definitions in your answers, and mention the historical distinction if it helps.

How they look on stage

Acting. Both styles call for truthful, internally motivated acting with no playing to the audience. Naturalistic productions may go further toward minute, real-time physical behavior: actually cooking, cleaning or eating on stage.

Set. Realism typically uses a box set: three walls of a room, with real doors and windows, furnished believably. Naturalism tries to make that room complete and specific, down to wear and dirt.

Props. Realism needs props that look right. Naturalism prefers props that are real and are used for real.

Lighting. Both use motivated light, light that appears to come from a real source such as a window, a lamp or a fire. Naturalistic lighting tries to follow the time of day closely.

Sound. Everyday effects such as doorbells, rain and street noise, rather than underscoring music.

Staging a realistic or naturalistic play in a community theatre

Realism is the style most community audiences expect, but it can be expensive and unforgiving, because the audience compares everything to real life.

  • Choose selective realism. You rarely need a full box set. A few authentic, well-chosen pieces of furniture and props, plus good lighting, can suggest a complete room.
  • Prioritize what the actors touch. Spend your budget on props and furniture that are handled closely: cups, letters, chairs. Background items can be simpler.
  • Make practical props work. If a lamp gets switched on, a kettle boiled or food eaten, test it early and plan for safety and hygiene.
  • Work on listening. Realistic acting lives in the reactions. Rehearse scenes with attention on what the other actor is doing, not just on lines.
  • Mind the pace. Chekhov and other realists can drag if actors indulge every pause. Truthful doesn’t have to mean slow.
  • Consider the period. Ibsen and Chekhov were writing about their own time. If you stage them in period, research costume and etiquette; if you update them, make sure the social pressures still make sense.

Legacy

Realism became the default style of modern theatre, film and television. Naturalism’s detailed, unsparing approach survives in gritty social dramas and “kitchen sink” plays. Almost every major 20th-century movement, including expressionism, epic theatre and the theatre of the absurd, defined itself partly against realism and naturalism.

For the wider picture, see our guide to what style means in theatre or the quick list of styles in drama.

The complete guide to theatre styles

What Is Style in Theatre? Major Theatrical Styles Explained
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →